Nutrition Myths
Are ruminant trans fats healthy?

SUMMARY

  • Current science shows that there is no harm resulting from trans fats in their natural form, such as from dairy products and meats of ruminants (grazing animals).
  • Some studies show that the consumption of rTFAs may have positive health effects, especially on major diseases, such as cardiovascular diseases and cancers.
  • However, whether high amounts of rTFAs pose any health risks is not known and current studies are conflicting.
Advertisement

ON THIS PAGE

Are ruminant trans fats healthy?

Naturally occurring fats, also known as ruminant fats, are often compared to trans fats obtained from partially hydrogenated fats, which have been proven to be harmful to health.

Find out what ruminant trans fatty acids (rTFAs) are and what the latest scientific studies say about their health effects.

Where do ruminant trans fatty acids come from?

  • Food sources of ruminant trans fatty acids

    The most common food sources of naturally occurring trans fats are meat and dairy products from cows, sheep and goats, but also any other ruminant animals. These trans fatty acids have been a part of our diets since the agricultural revolution, around 10,000 years ago.

  • The process of creating rTFAs: bio-hydrogenation

    rTFAs are produced in the gut of grazing animals (ruminants). It is a natural process that occurs at a normal body temperature and pressure, using bacterial enzymes. (1)

    The process of rTFAs production is called microbial bio-hydrogenation, where unsaturated fatty acids are saturated with hydrogen by the microbes living in the gut of the ruminants.

    During this process, some of these unsaturated fatty acids are converted into saturated fats and some to trans fats. Cows fed with grass produce up to 5 times more of these trans fats than cows fed with grains. (2, 3)

  • Where are rTFAs more abundant?

    Dairy products contain up to 5% of rTFAs of total fat and beef and lamb up to 9% (in comparison to about 60% of industrial trans fatty acids – iTFAs – in partially hydrogenated oils). (4, 5) rTFAs cannot be removed from dairy products and meat.

    In countries that have imposed bans on iTFAs, most TFAs come in the form of milk and other dairy products and meat. Only a negligible amount comes from iTFAs.

    For instance, in Denmark, which banned iTFAs in 2004,  the average consumption of TFAs is 1.7g per day (ranging from 0.9-2.7g per day), and most comes from ruminant sources. Of the ruminant trans fats, 85% comes from milk and 15% from meat. (6)

  • Amounts of naturally occurring trans fats in commonly consumed ruminant products (7)

    FoodTFA (g/serving)
    Dairy products
    Cheese, cheddar (28 g, 1 oz)0.24
    Milk, whole (244 g, 1 cup)0.21
    Yogurt, plain, low-fat (255 g, 1 cup)0.06
    Meat
    Meat, beef, ground, 20.8% fat, raw (115 g, 4 oz)0.91
    Meat, beef, ground, 22.1% fat, raw (115 g, 4 oz)1.07

    Because of the low contents of rTFAs in dairy and meat products, it is difficult to consume them in high amounts.

    In countries where ruminant dairy and meat is consumed, it is estimated that the maximum intake of ruminant fats is 4-5 g daily. (2)

What are the components of ruminant trans fatty acids?

rTFAs mainly consist of two fatty acids:

  1. Conjugated linolenic fatty acids or CLA (rumenic).
  2. Vaccenic acid (VA) which makes up about 45% of rTFA and is partially converted to CLA by the bodies of both ruminants and humans.

These components are investigated the most. (1, 8).

Potential effects of naturally occurring trans fats

While there are many studies on iTFAs and the evidence of their negative health effects strong, the number of studies on rTFAs are limited by comparison. (9)

The current knowledge of rTFAs is mostly based on observational, epidemiological or animal studies, either in its natural form (e.g. consuming rTFAs in the form of milk) or using its pure components, such as CLA or VA.

The bottom line is that there are no results showing that rTFAs coming from milk and meat in its natural form, increase the risk of cardiovascular disease or cancers or have any other detrimental effect on health.

What has been found so far is that they may even have some positive health benefits (more studies are needed).

The following are the conclusions so far: (10, 11)

  • Naturally occurring trans fatty acids (rTFAs) – studies show that a daily consumption of up to 4g of rTFAs is not associated with coronary heart diseases. (2)

    rTFAs have been connected with a reduced risk of developing type 2 Diabetes.

  • Conjugated Linolenic Acid (CLA) – predominantly, found in milk, CLA is one of the major components of rTFAs and has been shown to have various health benefits: (12, 13, 14)
    Anti-carcinogenic properties (e.g. breast cancer) (15)
    Anti-diabetic properties
    Reduced numbers of myocardial infarctions
    Prevents the development of atherosclerosis
    Promotes fat reduction while improving lean body mass (16)
    Modulates immune responses
    Modulates inflammatory responses

    Please note that most of these studies are measuring the effects of extracted CLA, rather than in amounts naturally occurring in rTFAs. (17)

    Supplementation with CLAs may have also negative health effects in some people, such as effects on the liver function, glucose metabolism, oxidative stress and insulin resistance, especially in obese men. (18, 19, 20)

  • Special note on grass fed vs. grain fed ruminants.

    Meat from grass-fed animals contain more Omega-3 fatty acids and CLAs than meats from grain-fed animals.

    In fact, the contents of Omega-3 in grass fed cows is high enough to be considered by the Food Standards Australia and New Zealand as a good Omega-3 food source. (21)

  • Vaccenic acid (VA) – is another major component in rTFAs (45%).

    Vaccenic acid is partially converted to CLAs inside the human body.

    When considering the effects of vaccenic acid that occurs in its natural form in dairy and meats, no negative effects have been reported. (22, 23)

    When the vaccenic acid was tested in larger dosages (10 times more) than normally consumed from natural foods, it showed detrimental effects similar to those in the high iTFAs diet.

    These amounts of vaccenic acid, however, were artificially synthesized in the lab and don’t occur in such quantities in foods. (7)

Main conclusions of the major studies on ruminant trans fatty acids.

Some studies show that vaccenic acid may have anti-carcinogenic effects on breast cancer cases (17) and may have protective effects in diabetes. (24)

A 2015 double-blind, randomized controlled trial showed that when VA was compared gram for gram with iTFAs, the results on total cholesterol and LDL cholesterol were similar.

Although the study suggested that vaccenic acid may have similar effects on the risk of developing cardiovascular diseases (CDA), due to the blood cholesterol increase, it is important to note that although it raised LDL cholesterol, it also raised HDL cholesterol.

The overall effect on CDA from this study is not clear, since LDL cholesterol consists of both “bad” and “good” cholesterol. (25, 26, 27)

Another study found that the circulating blood triglycerides have a higher concentration of vaccenic acid in hyperinsulinemic and hyperglycemic people and higher concentrations were associated with insulin resistance. (28)

IMPORTANT NOTE: The positive effects of rTFAs are sometimes promoted by studies sponsored by the dairy industry. When searching for proof, consider who the sponsors are or any conflicts within the scientific studies.

Problems with the current studies

For ethical reasons, randomized intervention studies, which could show the extent of these fats on human health, may never be conducted. Most studies are done on animals or are observational or epidemiological.

Studies of iTFAs are easier to conduct and more abundant because they can be produced in high quantities using the partial hydrogenation process.  

Studies on rTFAs, on the other hand, are harder since they are available in very small amounts in their natural form. (9)

The current knowledge of rTFAs is mostly based on observational studies of these fats, either in  their natural form (e.g. consuming rTFAs in the form of milk) or using its pure components, such as CLA or VA.

The rTFAs’ molecular structure is slightly different from the iTFAs’.

Therefore, they have different effects in our body. More studies are needed to clearly show these differences.

Comparing the health effects of these two fats may be difficult, since there are other variables that may alter the results.

For example fats containing iTFAs are mainly unsaturated while rTFAs are mostly saturated. In addition, some fats may have higher omega-3 fatty acids concentration which counteracts many of the TFAs actions, such as inflammation.

CLAs are the most studied component of rTFAs, while VAs have not been investigated as much. (25)

The association with the risk of developing cancer has not yet been well studied. (29)

Some studies show that rTFAs alone (or their individual components, such as CLAs or VAs) may be responsible for some health benefits.

Other studies, however, suggest that the health benefits are due to other components that are present in foods containing rTFAs, such as dairy. (30)

Related Posts

What is margarine? Margarine is described as a concoction of artificially modified substances that was created as a cheap substitute for natural butter.
Why we are not protected in Australia and NZ against trans fats? Since there are no restrictions on trans fats production and their labelling is not mandatory, Australians and New Zealanders have no way to avoid foods high in industrially produced trans fats.
Medium chain triglycerides The interest in medium chain triglycerides has increased in recent years due to the popularization of coconut oil as a super food. Find out what are medium chain triglycerides and what is their association with coconut o...
Triglycerides – basic chemistry This article explains the chemistry basics for better understanding the triglyceride molecule. It will help you comprehend many myths about fats that are currently in circulation.
Trans fat foods you need to avoid Find out how to reduce your chances of consuming trans fats and which foods you need to avoid.
Advertisement
Advertisement

Get updates

Receive regular updates on nutrition myths, facts and curiosities. All based on the latest scientific evidence.