Nutrition Myths
Are the amounts of toxic metals in gourmet salts dangerous?

SUMMARY

  • The amount of toxic trace elements that may be detrimental to health is insignificant in any salt, and gourmet salts are not significantly different from other salts.
  • To reach toxic levels of any of these elements, we would have to consume amounts of salt that contain lethal quantities of sodium.
Advertisement

Are the amounts of toxic metals in gourmet salts dangerous?

Gourmet salts such as the popular Himalayan pink salt contain a number of trace elements, which include essential minerals and toxic metals.

While salt manufacturers make many health claims related to the abundance of minerals in those expensive products (read more..), the amount of toxic elements is usually not mentioned.

In fact, neither of these trace elements, whether toxic metals or essential minerals (read more..), are present in the gourmet salts in significant amounts.

The table below shows a range of the highest in trace elements of gourmet salts and the tolerable maximum limits of these toxins for comparison.

Also Listed is “table salt” information. Table salt is usually stripped from most trace elements during processing. Aluminium is often added in the form of aluminosilicate. (read more..)

Maximum amounts of toxic elements found in various gourmet salts

Toxic elementsArsenicCadmiumChromiumMercuryNickelLeadThalliumVanadium
Table saltn/dn/d2n/d20.440.84n/d
Salts most abundant of specific element.Kala Namak Black Mineral SaltHimalayan Pink Fine Mineral SaltAlaea Hawaiian Sea SaltKala Namak Black Mineral SaltHimalayan Pink Fine Mineral SaltSel Gris De GuerandeFumee de Sel Chardonnay Oak Smoked SaltKala Namak Black Mineral Salt
Maximum of any salt (mcg/g)0.10.0932.60.183.61.31.61.9
Tolerable rate of toxic elements for adults as per various recommendations3 mcg/kg of body weight / week (1)7 mcg/kg of body weight / week (2)150mcg/kg of body weight / week (3)1.6mcg/kg of body weight / day (2)1,000mcg per adult / day (4)50mcg/kg of body weight / week (5)Upper limit not available.1,800mcg per adult / day (4)
How many grams of salt an adult of 75kg would have to consume daily to reach the maximum safe level of this element?3218064,32695277412n/a947
NOTE ON THALLIUM

Although there are currently no specific safety guidelines for intake of Thallium, the International Programme on Chemical Safety Task Group has estimated that dietary thallium of approximately 11 mcg/day is unlikely to cause adverse health effects.

I have therefore set a reference intake of 11mcg/day as a daily reference intake for the above table (not an upper safe limit since it is not known. (3)

As an example that population in UK intakes about 0.7-0.8 µg/day from the diet. In the case of Thallium, 1 gram of the most thallium abundant salt contains 1.6mcg of this element. This would represent only about 7% of what is known as a daily safe intake.

The row “Maximum amount (mcg) per gram of salt” shows the maximum amount of each toxic element found in one gram of any salt.

Please note the row with the maximum tolerable rate of toxic elements for adults. Some recommendations are shown as mcg/kg of body weight per week and some as mcg of body weight per day. These depend on the how the recommendations are formulated for each specific element.

The last row in this table shows an example of how much a 75kg person would have to consume of a particular salt to reach the toxic level of each element.

This calculation only takes into consideration the intake of salt. Food and water also contribute to the daily intake of these elements.

In the table, however, it is shown that the amount of toxic metals in gourmet salt is significantly below the upper safe level, even in the most mineral abundant salts.

Gourmet salt is usually consumed by sprinkling it on our food at the table or sometimes in cooking.

It is not added to processed foods. The amount of salt that we consume at the table whether it is either table salt or gourmet salt is about 1 gram per day.

For additional explanation, please see section “How much of table salt do we eat per day?” in the article “Are the aluminium contents in table salt harmful?”.

NUTRITION FACTS VS NUTRITION MYTHS

You will find a summary of the most common nutrition myths and evidence-based nutrition facts here.

Related Posts

Avocado seed: is it healthy or harmful? Avocado seed has not been declared safe to consume, due to limited studies investigating the toxicity and safety of its constituents. See what is the evidence of the potential health benefits of eating dry or fresh avoca...
Flaxseed side-effects, risks and warnings Flaxseed side-effects related to GI system, anti-nutrients, absorption of nutrients and medications, hypersensitivity, allergy, pregnancy, and cancer..
Benefits and risks of eating canned tuna Benefits and risks of eating canned tuna. Mercury content is not the only risk! Why you should limit consumption of albacore tuna. What is a safe limit?
Why we are not protected in Australia and NZ against trans fats? Since there are no restrictions on trans fats production and their labelling is not mandatory, Australians and New Zealanders have no way to avoid foods high in industrially produced trans fats.
Side effects of caffeine – who is at risk? Caffeine is the most common legal stimulant drug in the world. Learn about the potential side effects of caffeine and when you should avoid it.
Advertisement
Advertisement

Get updates

Receive regular updates on nutrition myths, facts and curiosities. All based on the latest scientific evidence.